Pathways, limits and lessons of the Stop the SIMCE Campaign in Chile

  • Jorge Inzunza

Resumen

It has been almost 30 years since the first application in Chile of the SIMCE (the Education Quality Measurement System), one of the oldest standardized tests in Latin America. Its validity has been based on a complex interaction of interests that have strengthened it to become the main regulator of the Chilean education system (Campos et al, 2014). We can trace its origins to the dictatorship, and its continued development to democratically elected governments, both those on the centre-left and on the right (OPECH, 2005).

This political and technical consensus on the need for and appropriateness of a standardized test has been completely disassociated from the reality of schools. We can summarize the main consequences of the tests on school life as: student and teacher stress, the pressure to achieve better results, the selection of and discrimination against students who do not achieve high results and the concentration of teaching on Spanish and Mathematics. On the other hand, the observable effects on the education system as a whole have included: increased privatization of services in order to increase results, a decrease in hours spent on or the complete elimination of some subjects in favour of dedicating more time to those subjects that are measured, the hegemony of the SIMCE over the education research agenda and disproportionate spending on the development, application and improvement of the tool (Docencia, 2009; Inzunza, 2014).

Biografía del autor/a

Jorge Inzunza

PHD in Education (UNICAMP, Brazil). Bilingual teacher in the Delavan-Darien School District (Wisconsin).

Citas

AaS (a) [online]. Open letter for a new education

evaluation system [accessed on: March 12, 2016]. Available

at: <http://www.altoalsimce.org/wp-content/uploads/

/09/Propuesta_Sistema_de_evaluacion.pdf>

AaS (b) [online]. Proposal New Evaluation System

for school education. Discussion paper [accessed on

March 12, 2016]. Available at: <http://www.altoalsimce.

org/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/2013_Carta-abierta-Por_un_Nuevo_sistema_de_evaluacion.pdf>

Teachers College Chile (2006). Final conclusions

Pedagogical Curriculum Congress 2005, Revista Docencia

[Teaching Magazine], 28, 4-39.

Campos, J.; Corbalán, F.; Inzunza, J. (2014) Following

the development and legitimization of the Chilean

Education Quality Measurement System (SIMCE) In

Wayne, A.; Ferrare, J.J. Mapping corporate education

reform: Power and policy networks in the neoliberal state,

-125, New York-London: Routledge.

Teaching (2009). Standardization in Chile: a dangerous

habit, Revista Docencia [Teaching Magazine],

, 4-17.

Inzunza H, J.; Pino, M.; Oyarzún, G. (2014). Standardized

education in Chile, Idea Network, http://idea-network.

ca/research/standardized-education-in-chile

[accessed on May 15, 2016].

Inzunza H., J. (2014). Standardization in education:

anatomy of a deformation, Revista Docencia [Teaching

Magazine] n.52, 4-13.

(2015). The evil of standardized measurement

and strategies to overcome it (the Chilean experience),

Revista Intercambio 7(6), 27-30.

OPECH (2005). SIMCE: Critical assessment and

indispensable repercussions, Work Document N°1,

Santiago: Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Chile.

Publicado
2017-12-21